Nearly two decades of marketplace history behind the Card Consignor store.
eBay consignment for trading cards
Turn valuable Pokemon and TCG cards into cash without doing the work yourself.
Sell outright for a fast cash offer or consign to maximize value. Card Consignor reviews the cards first, then handles the selling work either way.
Cash offers availableConsign for upsideItemized payout records
What collectors say
Real reviews. Real buyers.
Verified feedback from eBay buyers, pulled from the public Card Consignor feedback page.
A real seller record clients can review before choosing to consign.
Proof that careful listings, communication, packing, and follow-through matter.
“Seller was great on communication and packaging for my WOTC promo! Arrived quickly and as described by the seller at a fair price!”
Verified eBay buyer
“Item is EXACTLY as described, and the seller went out of their way to ship in a very timely manner.”
Verified eBay buyer
“Amazing price, communication, shipping, packaging and everything was as described.”
Verified eBay buyer
“Seller shipped this in fanastic packaging that kept the card safe, and it's near-mint as described.”
Verified eBay buyer
“Item was as described, arrived quickly and was well packaged.”
Verified eBay buyer
“Card condition as described. Shipped and packaged securely.”
Verified eBay buyer
Quick review first
Have cards? Choose the easiest money path.
First time or coming back, start with a quick review. We can look at a direct cash offer when speed matters, or a consignment plan when the card deserves more marketplace exposure.
Fast cash reviewConsignment optionNo spreadsheet needed
Sell outright
Want the simple path? Send card details and photos for a cash buyout review. If the cards fit, you can take a direct offer instead of waiting on eBay.
Request cash reviewConsign for upsideWant to chase the strongest result? Approved cards get researched, photographed, listed, shipped, and tracked through final payout.
Start consignmentPrivate reviewYour collection details stay between us.
No blind shippingCards are reviewed before anything is mailed.
Clear money pathCash offer or consignment math is explained up front.
Submission intake
Start with a real review record, not a loose email thread.
The intake flow collects enough detail to make the first review useful, then keeps approval, shipping, release acknowledgement, and payout updates in one portal record.
Open intake formStart with name, email, card type, rough count, value range, and whether you want cash review, auction, or fixed price.
2-minute intakeUse the portal to add individual cards or a quick collection summary with album links, cert links, comps, or price targets.
Photos or links welcomeIf accepted, the portal confirms what to include in the box: name, email, submission ID, and fixed-price target when applicable.
No blind mailingHow it works
Portal first. Ship after approval.
The portal keeps the consignment process documented from the first review to the final payout. Once items are accepted, clients get mailing instructions, online release acknowledgement, shipment tracking, every card's eBay listing link and status, buyer-message notes, and itemized payout records in one place.
Quick submission for uncertain collectionsApproval before shippingTrack each card listing in the portal
Submit the card details
Share a quick collection overview or enter individual cards when you already have the details.
Get reviewed before shipping
Card Consignor confirms which cards or groups are a good fit before anything is mailed.
Send only approved items
After approval, accept the release conditions online, then add USPS tracking in the portal.
Track every listing
Each accepted card gets portal updates with its eBay listing link, sale status, and payout progress.
Listing strategy
Auction or fixed price, chosen before anything goes live.
Accepted cards get a planned route instead of a default listing. The right path depends on the card, market demand, target price, and whether speed or price control matters more.
Grading and sealed TCG strategy matter.Graded packs and sealed booster boxes can be accepted when authentic, clean, in demand, and worth listing individually.Compare PSA, Beckett, CGC, TAG, and PCG grading before paying to grade cards or choosing to sell raw.
Auction route
Best for reviewed TCG cards and select sealed items where market demand should decide the price. Auctions can start at $0.99 with no reserve when that strategy is approved.
Fixed-price route
For reviewed items with an agreed listing price of $250 or more. Fixed-price listings can stay active longer and may go live during the week.
Include the listing details
After acceptance, include your name, email, and submission ID in the box. If fixed price is requested, include the target list price in the portal and on the note.
Sunday auction cutoff
Items received by Sunday night can be considered for that coming Sunday's auction block. Later arrivals usually roll to the following Sunday.
Fee schedule
Simple payout estimates, no calculator needed.
Choose the final sale range and see the estimated payout before mailing anything. The percentages are kept simple so you can see the Card Consignor split before eBay's marketplace fee is deducted.
The chart shows the estimated payout before eBay marketplace fees. eBay fees are deducted from the final sale before payout.
Final sale price- service fee= before eBay fees
Card Consignor service fee12.65%-5%
Lower service-fee percentages apply as the final sale price increases.
Sale priceBefore eBay feesOur service fee
$50-$99.9987.35%12.65%
$100-$499.9989.35%10.65%
$500-$999.9991.35%8.65%
$1,000-$7,50095%5%
How to read itA $500 sale range shows an estimated 91.35% payout before eBay's marketplace fee is deducted.
Estimated payout percentages are before eBay's trading-card marketplace fee. eBay marketplace fees are deducted from the final sale before payout; buyer-paid eBay postage is separate. Materials/handling usually runs $1-$2 per card, and added insurance is deducted at cost on $100+ sales when needed.
$25+Accepted for review
Quick reviewNo spreadsheet required
Per itemClear payout records
What to send
Focused on TCG cards worth individual attention.
Card Consignor is built for Pokemon, Magic: The Gathering, Disney Lorcana, One Piece, select graded packs, and sealed booster boxes where careful presentation, pricing, and sale format can matter.
Good fit
Start around $25 expected sale value
Launch review starts around $25, subject to condition, demand, and handling fit. $50+ remains the strongest individual-card fit.
Protection
Ship after acceptance
Accepted cards should be sleeved and packed in top loaders, semi-rigid holders, or other card-safe packaging.
Strategy
Match the selling approach
Some cards fit auction. Others may benefit from Buy It Now, Best Offer, repricing, or buyer-message handling.
Items we do not accept.
A quick eligibility check keeps submissions focused on TCG items that make sense for consignment.
- Sports cards, memorabilia, magazines, books, toys, and other non-TCG collectibles are outside the current service focus.
- Bulk lots made mostly of low-value commons, duplicates, or unsorted play-condition cards are usually not a fit.
- Counterfeit, proxy, altered, inked, trimmed, or authenticated-questionable cards cannot be listed.
- Cards with major condition issues may be declined when the expected sale value does not justify individual handling.
- Items must be reviewed and accepted before mailing; unapproved shipments may be returned at the sender's expense.
Contact
Ready to turn cards into cash?
Send a quick note or create an account to start a review. Include the card types, rough count, notable values, whether the items are raw or graded, and whether you prefer cash offer or consignment.
Mailing address after acceptancePO Box 1072Odessa, FL 33556
Email Card ConsignorCreate accountView eBay store